Saturday, April 15, 2023

Movie #714: Kind Hearts & Coronets

Kind Hearts & Coronets is 1949 black comedy starring Dennis Price, Valerie Hobson, Joan Greenwood, John Penrose, and the great Sir Alec Guinness as the entire D'Ascoyne family. Suck it, Eddie Murphy. 

We open the night before Louis Mazzini, now the 10th Duke of Chalfont, is awaiting execution for murder. As he waits (in a lavishly appointed cell with a lovely bottle of wine, because rich dudes can't even die without the creature comforts) he writes his memoir of how he came to be in this predicament. 

Turns out that Louis' mother (Audrey Fildes) married an opera singer (also played by Price) for love rather than status and was summarily booted from the D'Ascoyne family; one suspects there may have been a sort of "ew, Italian" thing going on. The senior Mazzini dies immediately upon the birth of his son, leaving his widow to raise their son by working for a living, something she's had no training for her whole life. Eventually she dies in a carriage accident, her dying wish being that she be interred in the D'Ascoyne family plot, which the family refuses. 

Louis grows up doing the best he can, even proposes to his childhood sweetheart Sibella (Greenwood), who refuses and marries their other chum Lionel (Penrose) because like, he doesn't work the counter in a store like some kind of peasant. Louis dreams of becoming Duke of Chalfont, the title held by his family, and keeps tabs on how many people would have to die for that to happen. Morbid, but harmless...until fate puts him in the position of being able to actually kill one of them in an "accident," and that's when shit gets fucky, as they say in high society.

Louis embarks on a campaign of murder stretching over a couple of years, bumping off each of the elder D'Ascoynes in a variety of clever or outright ridiculous ways, until the only one left is the Duke himself; he's the only one that Louis murders face to face and explains what he's really doing. He's made Duke and marries Edith D'Ascoyne (Hobson), the morally upright and beautiful widow of one of his early victims. And then shortly thereafter, he's arrested for murdering Lionel, who came to him in a drunken fit begging for money and wound up with a dagger in him. Sibella, with whom Louis has been "intimate" lo these many years, neatly frames him, and here we are waiting for the noose.

Comedy is hard, and black comedy is even harder. You have to make the audience care about someone who's doing awful things, usually for selfish motives, and while pain is funny, if you linger too long on the pathos of the victim or the knock-on effects of, say, murder, you run the risk of devolving into some form of torture porn. That said, I think black comedy might actually benefit from a more staid and PG-rated approach, because if a lot of the violence and death is left implied, it's easier to laugh about it (the other option would be to go full Looney Tunes with it, but as soon as blood becomes involved it gets so much more visceral - see also Very Bad Things). 

In this case, Price plays Louis with some genuine grievance, but he approaches cold-blooded murder with such precision and patience that you never really lose sight of what a sonofabitch he is. Meanwhile, the D'Ascoynes are mostly awful people (maybe not Agatha, the suffragette), but their awfulness is the privileged obliviousness of British upper class, utterly confused by the notion that anyone would even think about changing their status. And then there's Sibella, who gets the better of Louis and offers him a way out if he murders Edith, but apparently doesn't take into account that he might just bump her off instead. 

Ending the movie with Louis facing justice would have felt anticlimactic, but ending it with him getting off scott free would have felt wrong, so I think the given ending - Louis trying to choose between his two women and then suddenly realizing he's written out his whole confession and left it in his cell - is perfect. 

All in all, it's very much a product of its time, but it's also black humor done near-perfectly. It'd be interesting to double feature this with And Then There Were None, a much bleaker take on multiple murder from around the same time.

My Grade: A-
Rewatch Value: Medium

Next up: Nope

No comments:

Post a Comment