Far away, the planet of Kypton is explod- wait, no, we're just zooming past all of the origin story shit and picking up three years after Superman (Corenswet) has appeared on Earth. Metahumans have been on Earth for centuries, and people are entirely used to them as a concept, although the political ramifications (particularly of something as powerful as Superman) are still getting felt out. And Supes crash-lands in the Arctic after having his ass kicked by the mysterious Hammer of Boravia, a metahuman apparently representing the titular nation ("Boravia," not "Hammer"), because Supes intervened and stopped them from going to war with a neighbor recently.
We very quickly learn, though, that all of this "Hammer of Boravia" nonsense is just a smokescreen cooked up by Lex Luthor (Hoult), in cahoots with the President of Boravia (Zlatko Buric), ultimately to get access to Superman's Fortress of Solitude to find a way to kill him. And while Supes takes on a giant monster with the help of the Justice Gang - Guy Gardner (Fillion), Hawkgirl (Merced), and Mr. Terrific (Gathegi) - he does! A message from Superman's parents (Bradley Cooper and Angela Sarafyan) that begins innocently enough turns out to be instructions to bloodily subjugate Earth, which immediately gives Lex the government authority he needs to capture and interrogate (and therefore kill) Superman.
Superman does indeed get captured and put in a pocket dimension with Metamorpho (Carrigan) as a cellmate, since he can create kryptonite, so it's up to Lois Lane (Brosnahan) and Mr. Terrific to save him!
There's a lot more, but that's the broad strokes. I really enjoyed this movie when it came out, and I still do, but some of the flaws are coming into focus on a rewatch.
For one thing, there is some really clunky exposition in this movie. It's introducing a shitload of characters and concepts very quickly so it does a lot of the initial work doing that by just telling us who they are. The movie assumes we already know the basics about Superman - origin story, basic character, powers, how he protects Earth - and that's fair, we don't need that spelled out. But a little more background on, say, Mr. Terrific would have been nice. If you're familiar with comic-book movies you can kind of accept some of the weirder shit here (pocket dimensions, shapeshifters, teleportation, nanites), but that leads into what I think might be the big problem here...
And that's that James Gunn knows we're all familiar with comic-book movies because we've been watching MCU movies for the past 20 years. He wants to get to the good stuff, where he pushes the envelope a little, but doing that requires the DCU to have the same footprint as the MCU and it just doesn't because of the mess Zack Snyder made. So he's trying to jump ahead to the bits where he can do more innovative stuff as a producer (such as, apparently, Clayface, though I haven't seen it yet).
Trouble is, as the DCEU taught us, you can't rush the foundational stuff. And when Superman is doing that work, showing us the relationships between Superman and Lois Lane, the staff at the Daily Planet, and letting Nicholas Hoult chew scenery and show us his intense jealousy and hatred, the movie works. Plus it's bright, it's colorful, and it does present some interesting takes on some characters (what if Krypto was...kind of an asshole? And I have to admit, it's a change from what we'd expect). I really do like the movie and overall I think it works, but I think Gunn did better work in the Guardians movies.
(Also, what's with Jimmy Olsen (Gisondo) being just fucking catnip to every woman ever? I mean, Skyler Gisondo is not unattractive, but he's not, like, a 10, right?)
My Grade: B
Rewatch Value: High
Rewatch Value: High
Next up: Suspiria







