We begin with the early life of Tom Powers (Coghlan Jr.) and his best buddy Matt Doyle (Darro) as Tom sneaks beer, steals things, hurts people for no reason, and gets beat with a belt by his father (hey, I think I might have spotted some of the problem!). And then he grows up into James Cagney (and Doyle into Edwards Woods), his older brother Mike (Cook) stayed in school and is a good, honorable fella who enlists in the Army just in time for the Great War, and Tom and Matt have started running with local small-time hood Putty Nose (Kinnell).
Putty Nose cuts and runs after Tom and Matt kill a cop (there are literally no consequences for this for them, ever), but fortunately Prohibition hits, and Paddy Ryan (O'Connor) is there to pick up the slack with his charming and kinda scary boss, Nails Nathan (Fenton). Tom and Matt live high on the hog, meet girls, Matt marries, Tom kicks his girlfriend Kitty (Mae Clarke) to the curb when he meets Gwen (Harlow), Nails dies in an accident and the whole thing erupts into a gang war that leaves Matt dead. Tom goes to singlehandedly kill the entire Schemer Burns mob, and predictably gets shot. He winds up in hospital until they kidnap him, kill him, and dump his dumb ass at home for his brother to find.
I'm being a little flip, but this is actually a really good movie. Cagney shows us a character that we would now call a psychopath, utterly without remorse, impulsive, violent, and so forth. In what is perhaps the most telling moment of the movie, after Nails dies Tom and Matt go to the stable, buy the horse that threw him, and fucking shoot it.
The plot would later be reused multiple times, often by Martin Scorcese. You can see the influence - guy rises in a criminal enterprise, gets too big for his britches or sticks around past when the getting is good, winds up dead. Except the vibe here is very much "hey, society creates people like Tom Powers and we're going to have to deal with that shit at some point." I was expecting this movie to be a lot more moralistic than it was; aside from the end plates it just kind of presents Tom as the monster he is but doesn't waggle its finger or shy away from showing how much fun he's having.
The Public Enemy is one of those movies that you feel like you've seen even if you haven't seen it, and I always love watching those because it's fun to see where tropes come from.
My Grade: A-
Rewatch Value: Medium-low, I think?
Rewatch Value: Medium-low, I think?
Next Up: Alvin & The Chipmunks: Road Chip. At least it's the last one