Saturday, October 28, 2023

Movie #756: Mister Roberts

Mister Roberts is a 1955 comedy based on a hit play (side note: can you imagine that there was a time in America where "based on a hit play" was any kind of selling point? Not musical, play) starring Henry Fonda, James Cagney, Jack Lemmon, William Powell, Philip Carey, and Ken Curtis.

The titular Mister Roberts (Fonda) is the cargo chief aboard the Reluctant (perhaps a little on the nose), a cargo ship in the Pacific during the last days of WWII. Roberts is good at his job and all of the men love him, but he's got two major problems. First, he's utterly dissatisfied with his work and wants to see combat, and second, the captain (Cagney) is a raging egomaniac and runs the ship like it's own personal fiefdom. Plus he's an idiot. 

(And I have to say, the captain's style of "leadership" rings really true, because I've seen too many people who are living examples of the Peter Principle and respond to their inability to do their job by consolidating and reaffirming the fact that they are in charge. But anyway.)

Roberts tries for transfers but the captain never approves them, and eventually the captain puts him in a difficult position: toe the line or else no one in the crew gets shore leave, ever. Realizing that the men's morale is already rock bottom, Roberts agrees, the men go ashore and act like drunken idiots (but like, in a cute way!), and immediately thereafter word spreads that Roberts is being a dick because he's bucking for a promotion even though that's completely out of character for him. 

(Side note: one thing I found a little suspension-of-disbelief-breaking was that no one in the crew had the wherewithal to say "hey, Mr. Roberts was totally on our side before our shore leave, and then the captain tried to cancel it at the last minute, Roberts went into his office, and then 10 minutes later we had shore leave but Roberts was being a dick. WHA HAPPUN". But anyway.)

Eventually, Roberts breaks and confronts the captain, the truth is revealed, the men help him get transferred, he gets sent to a battleship near Okinawa, and is promptly killed in action because that's what happens in war, so it was all for nothing, he could have stayed on the ship doing important work for his country but noooooo, he had to "see combat." Sensibilities may have shifted a bit since this movie came out. 

I'm being flip, but the movie is actually really funny. I haven't mentioned Jack Lemmon at all, but he plays the laundry and morale officer on the ship and has elevated avoiding the captain to an art form...but then winds up getting saddled with Roberts' old job when he leaves. The movie is really his arc as a character (well, Roberts to a degree, but in his case it's really more the plot happening to him rather than changing him), as he learns that playing it safe isn't going to make him happy and kinda makes him a coward. The funniest moments in the movie belong to him as he pursues, um, female companionship with a fervor that one can only admire, but watching Fonda's interplay with Cagney is also a lot of fun.

It's a fairly light movie and manages to make even Roberts' death feel sweet and noble rather than depressing and futile, which is impressive. 

My Grade: B+
Rewatch Value: Medium

Next up: Oculus

No comments:

Post a Comment