Wednesday, October 11, 2023

Board Game: Robinson Cruose: Adventures on the Cursed Island

No monkey butlers, sadly.

The Game: Robinson Crusoe: Adventures on the Cursed Island
The Publisher: Portal Games
Time: 2-3 hours
Players: Me, Michelle, Amanda

Game Play: Robinson Crusoe, despite the name, doesn't really have anything to do with the titular novel other than it concerns being stranded on an island. It's a cooperative survival board game, and holy shit there are a lot of moving parts. We start off choosing a scenario; the game book (which is the size of a decent-thickness magazine, as is common for such games) advises the first one, "Castaways," so that's the one we tried. In brief, we have 12 turns to build a roof, a palisade, and a woodpile that can be lit on fire should a ship happen by. Fail to do so, or if any character dies, we all lose. Easy-peasy.

Narrator: It was neither easy nor peasy

Game play progresses across six phases: Event (draw an event card, read it out, discover how you're screwed this turn, typically it takes resources away or limits your actions); Morale (if your Morale is positive, the First Player gets Determination tokens; if it's negative, them lose them); Production (gain resources based on what's available in your camp); Actions (a whole other thing); Weather (determine whether you lose resources to snow, rain, beasts, or all three); Night (eat or die). 

It legit took all three of us just to get the stuff out of the box and set up

It might seem from the above that the game is unforgiving. That ain't the half of it. The "Action Phase", which is really the meat of the game, is even more so. Check it out.

There are a number of actions to take: You can explore the island, uncovering new tiles and therefore new resources, places to move one's camp to, beasts to hunt, and scenario-related events. You can gather resources from tiles other than your camp. You can build stuff (which opens up into a whole other subset of stuff, because building Roof is different than building Weapons is different than making Items out of Inventions). You can hunt animals to get food and hides. You can hang out in camp and boost the Morale, or you can rest and heal. If you devote two action tokens to any of these tasks, you automatically succeed. If you just devote one, you roll three special dice, each of which controls a different aspect of the task: whether you get hurt in the process, whether you draw an Adventure card, and whether you actually succeed. 

Whew, is that it?

"Not remotely!"

Complications abound. Adventure cards typically give you the choice between discarding them, no harm, no foul, or taking an immediate benefit but shuffling them into the Event Deck, but when it comes back up it has a deleterious effect. If you have to pay a resource of any kind and you can't, you take a wound. Take too many wounds and your Morale goes down. Healing isn't especially hard, all things considered, but if you heal a wound and cross the "Morale barrier," it doesn't go back up. As such, it's possible to take a wound, lose Morale, heal a wound, and then take another wound and lose more Morale within one phase. Hunting is a good way to get resources, but you generally don't know what you're hunting until you commit and if the beast's strength is higher than the Weapon level, you might still kill it but it'll wreck your shit.

There's a lot going on, is my point

So anyway, we got to the 10th round and then died from snow.  

The terrifying blizzard

Opinions: In the excellent video game review series "Zero Punctuation," Yahztee Croshaw describes the "cockup cascade," a situation in games like Hitman where one mistake quickly compounds until it's easier just to reload a save. Robinson Crusoe is quite a lot of cockup cascading, and frankly I don't know how to avoid them yet because I've only played once. It is neither easy nor forgiving. There are a lot of rules that are important but that I didn't mention above.

But for all that, the game is fun. And, although there's a hell of a lot going on, the game board arranges the information such that you can find it and your eyes flow naturally over the board with the progression of the game. There are a few rules that aren't explained as well as they might be - the Build action in particular could have used more examples - but overall we didn't have difficulty playing the game except inasmuch as we couldn't make progress before a fucking hurricane came along and wrecked everything. 

Alas, poor carpenter

Keep? Yep!

No comments:

Post a Comment