Sunday, March 12, 2023

Oscars: The Year I Was Actually Offended

It's the 95th Academy Awards! I'm an Oscar nerd. No shame. But for the first time in the ~20 years that I've been following the Oscars, I'm actually kind of offended by a couple of the nominees. I'll talk about why down under Best Picture, but basically I'm annoyed that Avatar: The Way of Water and Top Gun: Maverick got nominated over other, more deserving films. That arguably happens every year, and people have different criteria for what "should" be nominated, and that's good. I just feel that both of those sequels were not just bad but aggressively mediocre, and there were a lot of better films that got left behind. 

With all of that said, there were also a lot of films that I thought were really good and moving and thought provoking, so it's not like it was a shit year or anything. Let's go through it! 

Best Animated Film: Nothing has the juice to beat Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio, but it's actually a pretty strong crop this year. Both Turning Red and The Sea Beast were sweet, but kinda what I expect from nominees in this category. We just watched Puss in Boots: The Last Wish last night, and I have to say I enjoyed it a lot more than I was expecting to, between the painting-like animation, Antonio Banderas' performance (I mean, plus the fantastic supporting cast), and the multiple converging storylines. And then there's Marcel the Shell With Shoes On, which I thought was very cute and funny, but I'm a little salty that that gets a nom here when The Lego Movie didn't. 

At the end of the day, though, Pinocchio takes a familiar tale and frees it from the yoke of Disney's interpretation, which is no mean trick. And it has all the hallmarks of Del Toro, including kids on the precipice of war, fuckin' weird monsters, and a fresh look at humanity.

My Choice & My Prediction: Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio 

Best Actress: Strong category this year, with perhaps one exception. We've got our probable winner, Michelle Yeoh, whose nomination is long overdue but who fucking killed it in Everything Everywhere All At Once. Thinking about it now, we saw some of the same vulnerability and strength here that we saw in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (for which she should have been nominated, dammit). And then there's the controversial nomination of Andrea Riseborough (controversial inasmuch as there was apparently some shaky campaigning going on, but the Academy let the nom stand). I actually think her nomination was very much deserved - To Leslie wasn't my favorite movie of the year or anything, but her performance (as well as the supporting performances of Marc Maron, Allison Janney, and Andre Royo) were well worth watching. 

The other elephant in this particular room is Cate Blanchett, and like, well-deserved nom for Tár. I got grouchy about her nomination, to say nothing of her win, for Blue Jasmine, but watching her unravel and wreck her life in Tár was pretty amazing. I guess I couldn't get mad if she wins.

The other two noms: Ana de Armas for Blonde and Michelle Williams for The Fabelmans. Hrm. Ana de Armas was amazing Blonde, though I didn't love the movie itself. I'm happy that she got the nom, and I look forward to her future work (maybe in something a little less icky). But Michelle Williams getting nominated over, say, Viola Davis for The Woman King or, heck, Janelle Monáe for Glass Onion bugs me. Williams is a good actress, but I have to say, I don't think this performance was worth the nom, and I think Williams has kinda coasted on Brokeback Mountain and Blue Valentine a bit. And, I think she got swept into the nom by The Fabelmans' momentum.

My Choice & Prediction: Michelle Yeoh

Best Supporting Actress: I admit to having a lot of conflicted feelings here, in a good way. This is a really strong category this year, and I don't know which way the Academy will go, but it'd be almost impossible to truly fuck it up. We've got noms for the incomparable Angela Bassett (Black Panther: Wakanda Forever) and Jamie Lee Curtis (Everything Everywhere All at Once). Curtis has never been nominated (wtf), and Bassett got one nom for What's Love Got to Do With It, and both of those things seem criminal. And ordinarily I'd be perfectly happy if either of them got it, except that we've also got Hong Chau, who was amazing and moving in The Whale, Kerry Condon, who provided the only real grounding influence in The Banshees of Inisherin, either of whom would also be great choices. I'd be less OK with Condon taking it, not because it's not an Oscar-worthy performance but just because there are better and more deserving choices. 

Speaking of which, Stephanie goddamn Hsu. Look, everyone in Everything Everywhere had to effectively play multiple roles, but Hsu also had to bring across the nihilism and sadness of someone who tried to understand and see everything and just be destroyed by it. I think she is my pick for the award, the question is going to be whether Curtis' nomination splits the vote enough for Bassett or Condon to take it (I don't think it's gonna be Chau).

My Choice: Stephanie Hsu
My Prediction: Ermmm...I guess I'll call it for Jamie Lee Curtis, but I won't be surprised to be wrong

Best Actor: Another strong field! The big news here is Brendan Fraser's strong comeback in The Whale, and his performance (really, the acting generally) are what make it. Then again, if I'm honest, there are bits that feel...a little overwrought, I guess? I don't know, it's so hard not to root for him. But then again, a lot of the articles I'm seeing are really down on the movie itself, and that might be enough to knock him out of the box.

His biggest competition is probably Austin Butler for Elvis, which bugs me a little because I kinda wasn't a fan? When you're talking about biopics there's always the question of whether you're getting a performance or an impersonation, and I don't know here. He's very much the centerpiece of the movie, though, and he definitely put in the work, but he ain't my pick here.

It's interesting to me that Paul Mescal got nominated for Aftersun. I'm all for movies that portray the reality of depression, but I felt like Aftersun could have gone a little harder or been a little clearer. And, again, there were no actors of color that deserved a spot this year? C'mon now. 

So that leaves us with Colin Farrell for The Banshees of Inisherin and Bill Nighy for Living. I'd actually be fine with either of them winning; Farrell brings across his rather simple character in Banshees perfectly, and brings him through a real live character arc, which is always fun to watch. Likewise, Nighy's character in Living coping with the harsh realities of his life, but in an inimitably British (read: repressed) way, was one of my favorite performances of the year.

My Choice: Bill Nighy
My Prediction: Austin Butler

Best Supporting Actor: This one is pretty much a lock for Ke Huy Quan, as it should be. But Brian Tyree Henry also gave an Oscar-worthy performance in Causeway, although I don't think he's got the momentum to win this. We've got two more performances from Banshees nominated, Barry Keoghan and Brendan Gleeson, and while both were good roles I have to say that Gleeson turned in the more compelling one (and, why not, let's again grouse about how the Oscars needs an ensemble cast category). 

And then there's Judd Hirsch, and honestly, what the hell is he doing here? No disrespect to Hirsch himself, who is an amazing character actor, but he was on screen for like 45 seconds in The Fabelmans, he had maybe three scenes, and his role was, though important, not especially memorable? Why not Marc Maron (To Leslie) here, or Winston Duke (Wakanda Forever) or Leslie Odom Jr (Glass Onion) or Nicholas Hoult (The Menu) or etc?

My Choice & Prediction: Ke Huy Quan

Best Director: Fucking Spielberg. What's he doing here? Look, Alejandro Iñárritu's movie this year was wanky and self-indulgent, so it got a Cinematography nom and that was the end of it. Spielberg's movie was wanky and self-indulgent (though admittedly a lot easier to follow than Bardo), and it really should not have edged out every woman in the business.

Anyway. The Daniels are going to win this, which is fine by me. Everything Everywhere is an amazing and beautiful film and they deserve it. But who else we got? I'm happy to see Martin McDonagh here for his first Director nom, and I love the familiarity and sense of place he created in Banshees. Likewise, Ruben Östlund deserves his nom for Triangle of Sadness; I have quibbles with the movie but they're mostly screenplay based (which is also Östlund, but whatever). Todd Field for Tár, eh, I dunno I guess. He's another one that might have made way for a woman or minority director, but I can't fault the talent that went into the movie.

My Choice & Prediction: The Daniels

Best Original Screenplay: Fucking Spielberg...wait, this is just the same thing again! And I have similar thoughts, frankly. The Daniels are going to win (they goddamn better), Spielberg shouldn't be here, McDonagh should be, but I'm unsure about Tár and Triangle of Sadness. Both are well-written films, but neither of them end. Tár ends with our title character conducting the theme for a video game with a bunch of nerds, and I'm sure it means something to someone but it didn't feel like an ending to the movie. Likewise, Triangle of Sadness could have ended with Dolly De Leon deciding whether to bash Charlbi Dean's head in, but then there's this weird shot of Harris Dickinson's running through a field, and it just feels disjointed (RIP Charlbi Dean, by the way). 

All of that in mind, I'll be very surprised if Everything Everywhere doesn't win, but some of the other nominees annoy me.

My Choice & Prediction: Everything Everywhere All At Once

Best Adapted Screenplay: Some of my favorite movies of the year wound up here. To wit: Glass Onion: Stupid Subtitle That a Producer Added builds nicely on the character established in Knives Out, and manages to be really topical (more so than Rian Johnson realized, I'm sure, because Elon Musk hadn't shown his entire ass when the movie was made). Likewise, Living, as I mentioned, was a movie I found sad and beautiful and moving and touching on themes of community and doing one's best in the face of societal bullshit, but also has a tragic side that I really loved. If you're gonna remake Kurosawa, you'd better not miss, and I think Living really hit the mark. 

I haven't read All Quiet on the Western Front, but Michelle tells me which bits were added for the movie, and based what little I do know I think the changes that they made were appropriate and the themes of the story come across. And then we have Women Talking, which manages to feel like a play more than a movie, and bring across some really hard and brutal subject matter without feeling gratuitous (like Blonde). Also, they nominated Sarah Polley here instead of for directing, which means this is probably where Women Talking will get recognized, if at all.

Oh, wait, fucking Top Gun: Boomers On Parade got nominated here. What the tapdancing hell. Well, it ain't gonna win (if it wins anything it'll be in a technical category). 

So what has the juice to win? I'm guessing it'll come down to All Quiet or Women Talking, and flipping a coin I think I'll go with the latter.

My Choice & Prediction: Women Talking

Best Cinematography: Just watched the last one in this category last night, in fact! That'd be Bardo, it's not going to win, but that's definitely the category that movie should have gotten the nom for. 

Beyond that, we have Elvis, All Quiet on the Western Front, and Tár, plus Empire of Light. Now, I quite enjoyed Empire of Light, and while the cinematography didn't leap out at me particularly, the nomination is for Roger Deakins and betting against him is never a great idea. Mandy Walker (Elvis) is also getting buzz. And I have to say, the camera work in Elvis is impressive, if a little spinny at times for my taste. Incidentally, Walker is only the third woman ever to get this nomination. 

I don't think it's going to be Tár, because I think what's spectacular about the other ones is the cinematography, but past that I don't really know.

My Choice: All Quiet on the Western Front, I guess?
My Prediction: Elvis, I guess?

Best Picture: OK. So let's run these down. 

Women Talking, Triangle of Sadness, and All Quiet on the Western Front aren't winning. I mean, anything is possible, obviously - I never would have predicted Parasite to win - but I think that there are other movies in the mix that have too much momentum, support, and narrative behind them to win. And let's be honest, a big part of winning a Best Picture Oscar is your movie's story - not the story that the movie is telling, but the story of the movie. As well done as all three of these are, they don't have that.

And breaking things down a little further, I think All Quiet is...almost perfunctory? Like, it's a war movie, and the only novel thing is that it's told from the perspective of the "bad guys," but it's based on a book a lot of people read in school, and I don't think the Academy will rank it high enough to take the trophy. 

Likewise, Triangle of Sadness, for as much as I enjoyed it (right until the end), I think that expecting a bunch of rich people to vote for an "eat the rich" movie that involves so much barfing is probably a little too much to ask. And Women Talking is a slow boil, maybe too slow to win. 

So let's move past those, and into two more movies that won't win, but that actively offend me for their presence here. That'd be the two sequels: Top Gun: Maverick and Avatar: The Way of Water. Christ on a stick.

Top Gun: Who are we fighting? What foreign nation is drawing a deliberate act of war, but that doesn't merit a name drop? Why did this movie need to exist when the circumstances in the story are more contrived than any popcorn action flick I've ever seen? Also, it is beat-for-beat the same movie as Top Gun, except they didn't have anyone they could kill off to motivate Maverick (Iceman doesn't count). Also also, the movie is full of cringe-worthy military propaganda, and the most cringeworthy "let's all say our superhero names" scene I've ever seen.

I'm not disputing this movie's right to exist or to delight the aging Boomers and Gen-Xers that loved Top Gun back in the day (I rewatched it recently and I don't think it was good back then, but whatever, I'm not the target audience). But what the fuck is it doing here? It's a mediocre sequel, at best, and it got the nom instead of (insert about 20 movies here)?

Avatar: Jesus, this one was worse. James Cameron wants so badly to have a Navi Cinematic Universe, but all of the crap he's doing is so derivative of other properties. I couldn't tell Jakesully's kids apart, and I can't remember their names now (Num-num? Dookie? Loquat?). We couldn't just have unobtanium (jesus that's still so dumb) be the MacGuffin, we had to introduce Unobtanium II: Whale Juice so that we could have this utterly useless Ahab plot? And Jemaine Clement, what are you doing here? (Getting paid a boatload of dollars, I suspect.)

The movie starts about eight different plots that it doesn't finish, and then just dangles its "check out Avatar 3: The Fire Nation Attacks!" dingleberry. And again, fine, I don't begrudge anybody that. But it should not be a Best Picture nom, and it doesn't deserve as much analysis as I'm forced to give it. Blargh. 

Right, now that's over, let's move on to the ones that might actually win. That'd be Elvis, The Fabelmans, Tár, and Everything Everywhere All At Once. 

I'd like to count out Fabelmans. Again, self-indulgent, wanky, too long, and does nothing except fulfill this year's "movies about making movies" quota. I'd like to count it out, but it's Spielberg and it's inoffensive, so I dunno. It was better than Licorice Pizza, anyway. 

I don't think Tár is going to win. I think if there's an upset here, it'll be Blanchett beating Yeoh for Best Actress, but I don't think Tár has the widespread appeal it needs to win. It's not really about cancel culture, and honestly the whole thing improved for me when I started looking at it through a more Gothic lens, but I don't think that's going to be something the Academy voters get into. 

Elvis...I think it's unlikely. Again, feels perfunctory, like here's this year's installment of Ray/Walk the Line/Bohemian Rhapsody etc. I was actually hoping it would be a little heavier on the Luhrmann, like really go in for some anachronism and some weird camera tricks and so on, maybe a little closer to Rocketman (another one for the list). 

The Banshees of Inisherin was probably my second-favorite of the Best Picture noms. And sure, some of that is because I relate to Colin Farrell's character. Waking up one day and discovering that people that you love and respect no longer want anything to do with you is, for want of a better word, traumatic, even if you know why it's happening, but in true McDonagh style, the story doesn't stay on that point, but lets it evolve and get completely out of hand. It's fascinating and heartbreaking to watch two people who clearly have a great deal of love for each other decide to become enemies. And then in the middle there's Kerry Condon, who has the line of the movie: "You're all fucking boring, with your piddling grievances over nothing!" I love tragedy, I love bittersweet, and I love a movie that isn't afraid to be sad but also have some fucking resolution at the end. But I do not think Banshees is taking home gold.

And that leaves us with the rightful and probable winner, Everything Everywhere All At Once. Look, I'm not gonna pretend it's for everyone, but that's good. Top Gun is for everyone. Movies for everyone tend to be weak because they're not about anything. Everything Everywhere is weird, and it embraces the weirdness and beauty and chaos of family and pain and depression and banality and adds googly eyes. And as a parent of children who are growing up in this world where some days everything seems like the black bagel of doom, having a movie that highlights a simple truth I feel every day - to wit: I would ignore the swirling madness of power and possibility because you are that to me, my sons - is refreshing and weirdly empowering.

My Choice & Prediction: Everything Everywhere All At Once

No comments:

Post a Comment