Sunday, March 15, 2026

Oscars: Fingers Crossed, Hulu

Once again, 'tis time for the Academy Awards! And once again, I get to listen to a bunch of "the Oscars are so irrelevant lol" jokes. Traditions are nice.

Kind of a weird year. There are a bunch of nominees that I think are really strong, and then a few that, like, I see the appeal, but I have niggles. And then there's F1, that seems to have been sent a Best Picture nom by mistake. (That's harsh, but like, it really is three Top Gun plot points in a trenchcoat.)

I don't really have much of a hot take to start us off, though. I could talk about how it was sort of surreal watching It Was Just An Accident last night, an Iranian (in part) film made before we went to war with Iran, but I don't have much to say other than "fuck", so on we go, I suppose. Here's my predictions and choices for 10 categories. 

Best Supporting Actor: Gotta start somewhere, let's start here. I think we can count out Jacob Elordi. Most of the conversation I've seen hasn't really included him as a serious contender, and honestly Frankenstein didn't hit as well as it might have (I have thoughts on that, but we'll get to them later). Likewise, I don't think I've seen Stellan Skarsgård mentioned as a possible winner much. Skarsgård is one of those actors that I think deserves the nom for his career if not for this role in particular (not that I think he doesn't deserve it for this role, I'm just saying), but I don't think he's likely to seriously enter the contention.

Which leaves two noms from One Battle After Another and one from Sinners. Delroy Lindo is another one of those actors who deserves the nom on a career basis, but actually I thought his nom for Sinners is well-deserved anyway. Sean Penn's was my favorite performance in OBAA, and voters might find the movie and his performance generally topical enough to vote for. Likewise, Benicio Del Toro's character in OBAA was one of the more interesting (and likeable), though I have niggles about that movie (again, anon). Possible the vote might split.

I think Lindo's going to take it, and I'm good with that.

My Choice & Prediction: Delroy Lindo

Best Actress: No particular order to these, wooo! Anyway. Apparently Jessie Buckley is the favorite here, and she kills it in Hamnet, so that tracks. I don't think Emma Stone is taking it; the strength of Bugonia is more about the weird-ass script and direction and Jesse Plemmons (who should have been nominated over either Penn or Del Toro, in my humble opinion). Plus she just won for Poor Things not long ago. 

Likewise, I think we can count out Renate Reinsve. I remember seeing buzz about her when the season began, but it's kinda died down. There's still buzz for Kate Hudson, which I get, I guess, though hers was the weakest of the five performances, in my opinion. (Maybe tied with Reinsve, but that's largely because I have trouble remember which daughter was which in Sentimental Value.)

And that leaves Rose Byrne, and holy shit. I saw If I Had Legs I'd Kick You pretty soon after the noms came out, but it's a movie that stuck with me. I was struck at the time by how closely the plot resembled Uncut Gems (and therefore Marty Supreme), and lo and behold, look who pops up as a producer? But like, Byrne is in virtually every shot of the movie, and she is freaking amazing at depicting this woman just slowly breaking down (I've seen a theory that she's not really a therapist, but all her "patients" are just sides of herself that she's trying to deal with). 

My Choice: Rose Byrne
My Prediction: Jessie Buckley

Best Director: Why not! There are no rules! Anyway. I am here for Ryan Coogler. I'm always happy for [not white men] to win these awards, and I think that Sinners is an amazingly well-directed movie. I think, likewise, that Chloé Zhao could come away with her second win and that'd be fine. 

Of the others...eh. I kinda thing Paul Thomas Anderson peaked with Boogie Nights, fight me (maybe There Will Be Blood). In any case I wasn't a fan of OBAA generally and certainly not of the direction. Joachim Trier, I dunno. Sentimental Value is one of those movies that I recognize that it's good, I love the performances, but I think it's this year's "movie-about-moviemaking" wank, and I'm just not that interested. 

My Choice & Prediction: Ryan Coogler 

Best Actor: The disadvantage to just doing these in random order is that I'm feeling scattered. Oh well. Here we have Leonardo Di Caprio once again, but I don't think he really should be here rather than Supporting Actor (I actually forgot it was Sean Penn in that other slot and not him for a second). He was getting buzz earlier in the season, but it's kinda come down to Michael B. Jordan and Timothée Chalamet, from what I've been reading. Jordan won the SAG, Chalamet won the Globe, who knows. Chalamet has kinda been acting like a dick in interviews of late, and I don't know if that's gonna hurt him or not. I think Sinners' great visibility and the fact that Jordan played a duel role is likely to help.

What of the other two? I see a lot of praise for Ethan Hawke in Blue Moon, and having seen it, his performance is definitely the strength of the movie, but I'm not sure it hit hard enough to pull votes from Jordan and Chalamet. And I definitely think not enough people have seen The Secret Agent to vote for Wagner Moura.   

My Choice & Prediction: Michael B. Jordan

Best Supporting Actress: Some really strong performances here. I don't think Wunmi Mosaku is likely to take it, though if by some weird twist she did I'd be fine with that. I think that Sinners is more likely to get awards in other categories here. Likewise, I don't think Teyana Taylor is going to take it for OBAA. I think if she'd been in more of the movie, if we'd learned a little more about her character, she might have had a better shot.

So that gives us Amy Madigan with her incredible performance in Weapons and two noms from Sentimental Value. I actually really liked Elle Fanning's performance; it was probably my favorite in that movie. Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas acts as a center for it, and as I'm reflecting more on the movie, it actually wouldn't be terrible if she won. Really the only nominee that would annoy me if they won this award would be Taylor, I think.

But Amy Madigan has been getting a lot of buzz, she won a SAG and a Critic's Choice (but missed the Globe to Taylor, actually), so I'm feeling fairly confident calling it for her. 

My Choice & Prediction: Amy Madigan

Best Original Screenplay: Well, I think we can discount Blue Moon; again, I don't think it has the visibility, and certainly not up against three Best Picture noms. Of those, I think that Sinners is most likely to take it. Might the Academy choose to recognize Marty Supreme or Sentimental Value here? Maybe. If that happens I think Sentimental Value is the more likely upset.

But I do want to mention It Was Just An Accident. I always think awards should be used to reward innovation, courage, and originality, and Jafar Panahi made this movie illegally in Iran and is now facing an in absentia prison sentence for "propaganda." I don't know if that is going to make a difference to Academy voters, or enough of a difference to overcome the disparity in visibility between this and the other movies, but honestly, I think it's worth celebrating. As much as I loved Sinners, and as much as I think there's innovation and courage there to celebrate, it doesn't really compare.

My Choice: It Was Just An Accident
My Prediction: Sinners

Best Adapted Screenplay: As usual, I have almost no familiarity with the source material for these movies (other than Frankenstein, which I've read, though it's been a while). I know Bugonia is adapted from a Korean film, but reading the synopsis, it looks like the American remake followed it pretty closely. Hamnet is based on a novel, as is OBAA (by Thomas Pynchon because of course it is), and Train Dreams is based on a novella. So what do we think?

As much as I love Guillermo Del Toro, and as beautiful as Frankenstein was, I don't love it as an adaptation of the novel. I think Del Toro let his admitted love and sympathy for the Creature get in the way of the story. There are decisions I really love, but they have more to do with cinematography and casting than the script. I think I've been pretty clear that I didn't much dig OBAA, and a lot of that is because of the script - I think the characters are often kind of shallow and simplistic and under-explored, I think that there are some weird plot decisions (it's very strange to me that Chase Infiniti's character leaves her cell phone on even after it becomes clear to her that these people are here to help her, for instance).

I really loved Train Dreams, and though it's again more about the look, I did love the script. That's true of Hamnet, too; the shot towards the end of the audience reaching out for Hamlet is really moving. How much of that is screenplay? I don't know. 

I think, unfortunately, that OBAA is likely to take this award and that annoys me, because I think pretty much all of the other nominees are more deserving. Which one would I prefer? It's kind of a toss-up, but I think Bugonia. I like the weird stuff.

My Choice: Bugonia
My Prediction: One Battle After Another

Best Animated Feature: I actually managed to see them all this year; I thought I was gonna miss Arco, but then it popped up on streaming. I don't think Arco has a shot, mind - the animation style looks too old-fashioned, plus there is no way it has the juice to beat Zootopia 2 and K-Pop Demon Hunters. The award is definitely between those two, so let's talk about the others real quick.

I had actually completely forgotten about Elio until yesterday when Michelle and I were talking about the nominees and she reminded me. It's not bad, but like Elemental before it, it's just Pixar bein' Pixar. If Disney would grow some guts and actually commit to putting some gay content in their movies, they might actually shake things up to get some eyeballs on movies like this (there was meant to be content implying or outright stating that Elio was gay, but NO CAN'T HAVE THAT MOVIE MIGHT NOT PLAY IN CHINA or whatever). And as a result, it's just another funny, cute, well-animated movie about a misfit with a dead mom.

And that leaves Little Amélie or the Character of Rain. This is a really beautiful film from the perspective of the title character from conception to when she kind of develops some theory of mind and keys into the people around her. I fully admit that childhood language development is an interest of mine and this movie is a really fascinating depiction of that. This isn't gonna win, but it's at least my second choice.

So: Zootopia 2 or K-Pop? I gotta go with K-Pop, myself. Once again, I prefer to see things that we haven't seen before get rewarded, and although the plot isn't exactly ground-breaking, the visuals, the music, and script are all really well done. I liked Zootopia 2 just fine, but it's a sequel. 

My Choice & Prediction: K-Pop Demon Hunters

Best Casting: New category this year! As such, I have no idea how to call it! But I'm gonna talk about it anyway! So here we have five of the Best Picture noms. Which was the best-cast (discounting lead roles, which I'm sure were chosen by the directors)?

I think that One Battle After Another, again, doesn't spend enough time with any particular character, and the characters that I remember are all the leads anyway. I think The Secret Agent, again, is probably not visible enough to get this award (though Variety lists it as their "Could Win" slot for this category, so maybe they know something I don't). 

That leaves Hamnet, Sinners, and Marty Supreme, all of which were really well cast. I think that for Hamnet, though, mostly I remember Jessie Buckley and Paul Mescal. Between Sinners and Marty Supreme, I think I could go either way, so I'd rather go for Sinners because I liked the movie more.

My Choice & Prediction: Sinners

Best Picture: OK, then! 

It's always interesting to me to look back on these movies a year or two later and see which ones I want to watch again. Like, I loved The Brutalist, it was my choice for Best Picture last year (though I was very much on the fence), but I have no particular desire to watch it again. Likewise, I called 2024's Best Picture for Oppenheimer, but my choice was Poor Things, and looking back I stand by that, though I find myself thinking about Anatomy of a Fall pretty often, too. 

This year is interesting in that the movie that got not only the most nominations but the most nominations ever is a movie that I really loved, and that did good box office (that'd be Sinners). The other frontrunners, OBAA and Marty Supreme, are more traditional Oscar stuff, either because of the film style, the filmmakers, or the subject matter (throw Sentimental Value into that bucket, too). 

So, as in previous years, let's start with the stuff that ain't gonna win.

Train Dreams. Man, I loved this movie. It is not exciting or flashy or big. It's this slow, sad meditation on this one man's life, but leading up to him finally finding a way to connect with the world around him and break out of his own perspective - not unlike Little Amélie, as I think about it. There's no way this is winning, and I don't think I'd put it at my number one spot, but it'd be pretty high up.

Frankenstein was, like I said, beautiful, but it's too long and I think that voters may not dig some of the liberties Del Toro takes with the novel. Michelle is better able to comment on that than I am, but when I look back on the Best Picture noms, I remember Train Dreams and Hamnet so much more clearly, and that says something.

F1 can kinda go fuck itself. That's harsh. I dunno, it's not horrible, but I have the same questions about what it's doing here that I had about Top Gun: Maverick. It insists upon itself, let's say. But as I mentioned, it's just "sports movie: the vroom-vroom edition." 

The Secret Agent is good, it's topical, but I have about the same things to say about it as I did I'm Still Here, which was overall a better movie (and, honestly, if you wanted to nominate a movie with some resonance, It Was Just An Accident was right there). I don't think it's got much of a shot at Best Picture; maybe International Feature (though it's competing against Accident and Sentimental Value there, too).

Speaking of Sentimental Value, every year the Academy lauds a movie about movies, and frankly I think it's fine, it's subject matter that they know and can appreciate. I think this particular movie works better as a character study and a look at things like depression and generational trauma, of course. I don't think it's got much of a shot at Best Picture, but I've been wrong before.

Hament and Bugonia aren't likely to win. That's kind of sad (or would be, if the front runner wasn't so much to my taste), because I really love both of these movies. Bugonia is weird, but also manages to be somewhat topical because, like, we have seen how powerful conspiracy theorists can get if you don't shut them down right away (they're like Nazis in that sense - who are also conspiracy theorists, as I think about it). And, props to having an autistic character played by an autistic actor, that's cool. Hamnet, meanwhile, I found more accessible than the director's previous big movie, Eternals Nomadland. I've talked already about my favorite things about Hamnet, but I don't think it's likely to win Best Picture.

Our three contenders, here, are Sinners, OBAA, and Marty Supreme. My choice should be pretty obvious. I think both OBAA and Marty Supreme were too long, and both had subplots that could have been cut entirely and the movies would have been stronger for it. I think OBAA was really trying, or wanting, to be profound and topical, and instead wound up being...I don't know, childish? Even down to the names of some of the characters, they almost felt satirical at times, and if that's the aim, great, but fucking go for it then. And, again, the interesting characters never get quite enough to do.

Over on the Marty Supreme side of things, I liked it, but I did feel like it was beat-for-beat Uncut Gems (and, as I realized later, so was If I Had Legs I'd Kick You), and of the three Marty was the least successful implementation of that story. 

So that leaves us with Sinners. It's by no means perfect - there are some dangling plot issues (the Choctaw vampire hunters, f'rex), and you could argue, as did my friend Travis, that Sammie's magic of reaching through time with music wasn't as well examined as it could have been. But it moves through several different genres, it shows us people in the time period that we're not used to seeing, we get to see women having and enjoying sex, and it's a vampire movie, so there's a lot here to like, is what I'm saying. Oh, and it's got the best soundtrack in a movie since O Brother Where Art Thou? So, yeah, I think it's my choice.

My Choice & Prediction: Sinners 

No comments:

Post a Comment