Friday, October 3, 2025

Movie #882: The Thing (2011)

The Thing (in this case) is the 2011 prequel to the classic John Carpenter film of the same name, because there's this weird trend of doing sequels, prequels, or squeakquels that have the same title as the original film (see also Halloween 2018, Scream 2022, and any number of video games that do the same thing). It starts Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Joel Edgerton, Ulrich Thomsen, Eric Christian Olsen, Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje, Jørgen Langhelle, and a bunch of other Norwegians. 

Obviously the film focuses on the Norwegians who first encountered the titular "thing" in the 1982 film, so we start with a couple of given based on that movie - we've got the spaceship in the ice and the video footage showing them blowing up said ice to expose the spaceship, we've got the burned, two-face mass of flesh near the Norwegian's base, we've got the damage to the base itself, and of course we've got the opening scene where the two dudes in the helicopter kill themselves trying to kill a dog. The Thing (2011) gets us there by introducing the site through Kate (Winstead), a paleontologist specializing in working with frozen vertebrate remains, brought in to examine the "survivor" of the spaceship crash. The site is actually run by an arrogant wanker called Sander (Thomsen), but our other important character is, once again, the pilot, Sam Carter (Edgerton), an American, and like thank god because what if there were subtitles all the way through!?

Anyway, they dig up the alien-sicle, it thaws out and jumps up through the damn roof, and proceeds to slaughter and infect the rest of the crew. We wind up with everyone except Kate and the non-English-speaking dog keeper Lars (Langhalle) infected and/or dead. We last see Kate in a snow-cat ready to either freeze to death or try to drive to a Soviet base (and since we don't see the snow-cats in The Thing 1982 we have to assume she at least tried to make the drive) and Lars flagging down the refueling copter that arrives at base and chasing a husky out into the snow. 

So, this is by no means a good movie, but it's not terrible and I think it more or less succeeds at what it tried to do. The notion of telling the story of these hapless Norwegians is actually a fun idea. I wish they had just been...Norwegian, because introducing a bunch of other characters, including Americans, kind of muddies the waters somewhat. Likewise, though the movie is set in 1982 (immediately before The Thing, obviously), if you just showed me the movie past the title card telling us that I'd never have known. About the only nod towards rooting us in the decade is Kate listening to Men at Work's "Who Can it Be Now" (which, given that this property is based on a story called "Who Goes There?", is a nice touch). 

Likewise, the movie leans a little too much on CGI, but it's actually not as bad as I remember and there are some practical effects that look pretty cool. The Thing pulls out some more obviously insectoid or arachnid looking features that are gross and scary, and watching Olsen and Trond Espen Seim merge into the two-faced creature that the Americans take back to base in the first movie is pretty effective. Kate's idea of checking for tooth fillings (since the Thing can't replicate non-organic matter) as a way to identify humans is clever; it's something that the Americans could theoretically have thought of, but doesn't contradict anything.

About the biggest mark against this movie is that it's trying to worm itself into the same universe as The Thing, but it doesn't quite reach the heart and atmosphere of that movie, partially because it doesn't have the same claustrophobic and paranoid vibe, and partially because it feels new and slick and that's really not what the original went for. Both times I've seen it, I've immediately watched The Thing because I want to see the "real story," and I don't know if that's necessarily a point against the prequel, but it does make for a long evening.

My Grade: C+
Rewatch Value: Medium

Next up: Thor: Love & Thunder 

No comments:

Post a Comment