There's Something About Mary is a grossout/cringe comedy directed by the Farrelly Brothers and starring Ben Stiller, Cameron Diaz, Matt Dillon, Chris Elliott, Lee Evans, Jeffery Tambor, Lin Shaye, W. Earl Brown, Jonathan Richman, and Tommy Larkins.
Ted Stroehmann (Stiller) is a sad sack living in Rhode Island, pining away after a girl he knew very briefly in high school, the titular Mary (Diaz). After a disastrous prom date where he got his nuts caught in his zipper, we skip 13 years (which is good, because it beggars belief that he never saw Mary after that for reasons I'll explain in a moment) and find Ted still a sad sack, disrespected and put upon by everyone in his life, still pining for Mary. His best friend Dom (Elliott) encourages him to hire professional bloodhound and sleazeball Pat Healy (Dillon) to find her, because it's the 90s and you can't just Google someone. Healy finds her living in Miami near her developmentally disabled brother Warren (Brown), falls in "love", and moves there to try and seduce her.
Along the way, he discovers that Mary's friend Tucker (Evans) is really Norm, a pizza delivery guy (remember when pizza places had their own delivery people?) who is also gaslighting his way into Mary's life. Ted eventually follows, getting waylaid along the path by a murderous hitchhiker (Harland Williams, in one of the movie's many cameos) and...um...probably prison-raped by a whole bunch of dudes? (You don't see it, but it's implied and, as usual, played for laughs.)
The truth comes out, Mary quite naturally tells Ted to fuck off, but then wins her back by finding her ex-boyfriend Brett (Favre, who is apparently some kind of professional football-throw-guy?), whom she only ditched because of Norm's lies. Mary, of course, chooses Ted, because it's that kind of movie. All the way along, we have Richman and Larkins playing boring songs as a kind of Greek chorus.
What I think people remember about this movie is the few kind of funny moments - Diaz wiping jizz off Stiller's ear and using it as hair gel, which I realize sounds gross rather than funny out of context, but the truth is it's pretty gross in context, too. There was a time in the 90s where the Farrelly Brothers spun gold out of shit (often literally), and managed to rope legitimately talented people into their movies - before this, there was Kingpin, and then we had Me, Myself, and Irene and later Stuck on You. None of these movies are good and they're really not very funny, either, but there was a moment where grossout/cringe was big before it kind of got watered down into the purer cringe of Meet the Parents (Ben Stiller was and remains good at getting the shit kicked out of him for laughs).
I have no idea why I own this movie; I'm sure it was 2 bucks somewhere and I thought "eh." There's an extended version that's even worse, as it expands Jeffery Tambor's character and then has him get eaten by his own pet snake, and it crosses the line from gross and dumb into kind of horrific, so better that they cut that bit out. But the movie's humor doesn't work for me, aside from the grossout not being my thing, because the central premise doesn't work for me.
To wit: All these guys are obsessed with Mary, but why? She's not a bad or even flat person, she does have a personality, but she's not only a knockout but an orthopedic surgeon (side note: I have literally never met a female ortho. I'm sure they exist, but I used to work in an orthopedic research lab and came into contact with a lot of them, and I don't think I ever met a woman in the field, which I think says more about the field than anything else) so how does Norm, the stoner pizza guy, think he's in her league? She's kind and unquestionably charitable and giving, so why does the misanthropic and borderline sociopathic Pat think of her as anything but a sucker?
And more to the point: She is presented as being good-hearted and kind since high school, so it does not ring true that after Ted, whom she asked to prom because he stood up for her brother, injures himself to the point of spending weeks in the hospital, she would not check up on him. I know it's a silly thing to get hung up on, but if you're going to hang the central conflict of your story on a contrivance, it should probably be one that works.
Anyway, glad to be done with this and gladder I don't own any more of the Farrelly Brothers opuses. Opui. Opi. Whatever.
My Grade: D
Rewatch Value: IINSIAIFWT
Next Up: They
No comments:
Post a Comment