Thursday, August 1, 2024

Movie #801: Stuart Little

Stuart Little is family comedy based on the book by E. B. White and starring Michael J. Fox, Geena Davis, Hugh Laurie, Jonathan Lipnicki, Nathan Lane, Chazz Palminteri, Jeffery Jones, Bruno Kirby, and Jennifer Tilly. 

The Littles, Eleanor (Davis) and Frederick (Laurie), along with their son George (Lipnicki), adopt a mouse, Stuart (voiced by Fox) as a son. George has difficulty taking Stuart as his brother at first, especially when the extended family showers Stuart with gifts that are human-sized, but they bond over designing a remote-control boat for a Central Park boat race. And then the family cat, Snowbell (voiced by Lane) decides that the humiliation of having a mouse as a master is too great to bear and calls in alley-cat gangster Smokey (voiced by Palminteri) to get rid of him. He does that first by bullying two other talking mice (Kirby and Tilly providing voices) to pose as Stuart's birth parents, and then just cuts out the middleman and tries to eat him. Snowbell has a change of heart, Smokey and his gang are dropped into a river, Stuart realizes he truly is part of the family, all is well, roll credits.

This is one of those movies that I'm not sure why I own it - I expect it's something my kids liked when they were small, but I don't ever remember watching it (or the sequel, which I also inexplicably own). I didn't exactly hate it, but it's a very weird movie, and all the way through I was trying to figure out why it was striking me so strange. It's not the "family adopts a mouse" plotline; sure, that's odd, but small potatoes in the scheme of things. I think it was partly that the conflict in the movie comes from Stuart being like a mouse and different from his adopted family, but the fact that he is a mouse isn't really brought up? No one seems to care that this mouse, and other mice, wear clothes, talk, and can hail taxicabs, for crying out loud. Other animals don't seem to be able to talk to humans...except Stuart can understand cats, too, so why isn't that a bigger deal? 

It kind of borders on magical realism, in a way, and all through the movie I kept thinking that it felt like a Roald Dahl story. I'd never read the book, but looking up the synopsis, in the book, Stuart isn't adopted. He's just...born to the Littles, and he's a boy that happens to be the size and shape of a mouse. That that was too surreal for a movie studio to get behind in 1999, I can understand, but what I have trouble parsing is how surreal they still allowed the movie to be, while at the same time falling back on the same comic tropes (farting, things flying through the are, silly puns) that studios usually do. (Side note, though: At one point Smokey is referred to as "gatto di tutti gatti" and that I found funny as hell.)

At the end of the day it's a pretty harmless, occasionally funny family comedy, but it's one of those movies that if you were to hit a bong and think about it too hard, it would lead to some weird places. 

My Grade: C+
Rewatch Value: Low

Next up: Stuart Little 2

No comments:

Post a Comment