Split is a horror movie directed by M. Night Shyamalan and starring Anya Taylor-Joy, James McAvoy, Haley Lu Richardson, Jessica Sula, and Betty Buckley.
Casey (Taylor-Joy) is at a birthday party with her high school classmates Marcia (Sula) and Claire (Richardson) when they are kidnapped, taken away to a basement dungeon kind of a dealie, and every so often get visits from a mysterious man (McAvoy) who seems to change voice, bearing, and personality. In fact, the man, whose real name is Kevin, has 23 different "alters", each with their own lives and skills and so forth. That by itself would be weird enough, but several of them have formed a kind of cult around an emerging 24th alter, "the Beast," which is apparently going to emerge soon and, um, eat the girls.
The bulk of the movie is the girls trying to escape and, into the bargain, learning a bit more about their predicament (yay!) and losing articles of clothing (um). Casey is our POV character, but she is withdrawn and quiet and we learn in flashbacks that as a child (played by Izzie Coffey), she was abused by her uncle John (Brad William Henke). When her father (Sebastian Arcelus) died young, she went to live with John full time, and, well, there's no indication the abuse ever stopped.
Meanwhile, we get interludes with Kevin's therapist Dr. Fletcher (Buckley), who treats his disorder as some kind of superpower. There's a lot of talk about how suffering leads to the next stage in human evolution, or something, and hey, it seems to work, because when the Beast actually does emerge, it has supernatural powers - it can climb on walls, survive point-blank gunshot wounds, bend steel bars...but it does kill and eat Claire and Marcia. It nearly kills Casey, but then sees her patchwork of scars and burns (apparently self-inflicted) and realizes that she's been made "pure" through suffering, and leaves her alone.
Now, let's just admit up front that there's some kind of problematic shit going on here with the depiction of DID. Shyamalan kind of has this ongoing issue, if we're honest, of portraying mentally ill people as violent (see also Adrien Brody in The Village and Deanna Dunagan and Peter McRobbie in The Visit, and you could make the argument for Elijah Price in Unbreakable, for that matter). That's a kind of constant problem with a lot of horror movies. Also, one of the things about Shyamalan's movies, even the better ones, is that the logic starts to get wibbly around the edges - is the Beast supernatural? Superhuman? There's a line about him being "an amalgam of all the animals in a zoo" - like, what? That's a throwaway at the end of the movie and it doesn't really need to be there. It kind of ties in with his lair being below the zoo, but it still feels weirdly out of place.
But with all of that said, Split is a pretty effective horror movie. Taylor-Joy and McAvoy both turn in impressive performances, especially McAvoy. Say what you want about whether portraying folks with DID this way, but as an actor, portraying multiple characters is a lot of work, and McAvoy shifts not only voice but eye gaze, posturing, and bearing to the point that when Patrica or Hedwig or Dennis comes out, it's immediately obvious. The movie also has a nice build toward the arrival of the Beast. And, despite the "abuse victims are the chosen people" vibe the movie sends out, I like that Casey isn't superhuman because she was abused, and in fact kind of freezes up when she's kidnapped.
Shyamalan sometimes has a habit of getting really ponderous with his dialog, especially in his older movies (though I do wonder if it's because of studio influence, because while his post-Avatar movies are almost universally awful they also don't feel much like this first few). This one moves pretty well, and we don't spend as much time lingering between lines. We also wind up familiar with Kevin's weird lair, and as always, I appreciate a horror movie that lets us learn the space.
But I gotta talk about the Unbreakable connection. At the very end of the movie, we learn that we're in the same universe as Unbreakable, and we see David Dunn (Bruce Willis) pondering what to do about this "Horde" person. And it's a fun idea, tying Mr. Glass and David Dunn in to the more brutal and bestial world of Split. And then Shyamalan utterly failed to the stick the landing with Glass, and it kind of makes me wish that last scene hadn't been there, because I know how bad Glass was and it rather screws with this movie retroactively. Ah, well.
My Grade: B
Rewatch Value: Medium-low
Next up: Spy
No comments:
Post a Comment