Saturday, December 17, 2022

Movie #703: Pearl

Pearl is a horror movie with sprinkles of drama and comedy starring Mia Goth, David Corenswet, Tandi Wright, Matthew Sutherland, Alistair Sewell, and Emma Jenkins-Purro. It's a prequel to X, but we'll get to the Xs eventually. 

In 1918, rural Texas, the Spanish flu pandemic is raging and Pearl (Goth) lives on her family's farm with her mother Ruth (Wright) and her father (Sutherland). Her father has been rendered invalid by the flu, and can no longer move or speak, and since speech therapy didn't exist back then he doesn't have a way to communicate. Ruth is German, and therefore is justifiably paranoid about accepting help or even contact from anyone else, and then there's poor Pearl...

Actually, hang on. Pearl is fixated on getting off the farm and becoming a star, and sometimes she randomly kills the animals with a pitchfork and feeds them to the alligator that lives in the nearby lake, so um. 

Pearl gets to go into town to get her father's morphine sometimes, and sneaks off to see movies. On one such trip she meets the Projectionist (Corenswet), a well-meaning bohemian fellow who introduces her to stag films. Her sister-in-law Mitzi (Jenkins-Purro) tells her about an upcoming dance audition, and Pearl becomes obsessed, seeing it as the only way off the farm and out of her current life.

Now, I'd seen X, so I know what becomes of Pearl later in life, but I didn't know what to expect from this movie, and the beginning of the movie kind of made it seem like we were gearing up for a rise-and-fall kind of thing; Pearl gets to dance, maybe through crooked means, she goes on tour, and winds up back on the farm with her husband Howard (Sewell) eventually so that she's there to get her head crushed by a van in 1979 (spoilers for X). But no, not in the slightest. Pearl isn't particularly talented, and she can barely remain socially functional for a full conversation. She breaks down under pressure and starts crying and screaming, and she discovers that she doesn't have the slightest problem killing people as well as animals. Eventually, she realizes that she isn't meant for stardom, and resolves to stay on the farm and devote herself to Howard. 

All of that is very sweet, of course (except for the "killing people" bit), but Mia Goth acts the hell out of this role. A lot of times in our pop culture, psychopaths (in the cinematic rather than clinical sense) are depicted as geniuses or at least extremely cunning; Pearl isn't, and she's almost more terrifying because of it. Likewise, it's very easy to take an "evil" protagonist and then go too far making them sympathetic, and we do feel some sympathy for Pearl when her mother tries to cut her off from the outside world and refuses help from their in-laws out of pride...but then, we also feel for Ruth because we know what she's lost and, more importantly, that she knows exactly what Pearl is and her enforced isolation is keeping the world safe from Pearl as much as anything.

I rather suspect Pearl won't get any Academy attention because it's too gory and skating too close to the line of exploitation film, but that's a real shame, because both Goth and Wright turn in performances that are worthy of Oscar nods. Goth's monologue near the end as she works through her feelings towards Howard and the farm has gotten a lot of attention, but Wright's scene leading up the fight with Pearl is just as intense and impressive. 

I was also interested in whether Pearl stands on its own or if you need to have seen X, and my conclusion is that it greatly enhances the experience if you have, but it's an impressive bit of cinema either way. I was amused to note that Pearl's line in X, "you know I don't like blondes," had a pretty specific reason here. I also wonder if Howard ever learned what happened to his sister.

My Grade: A
Rewatch Value: Medium

Next up: Sky High

No comments:

Post a Comment