Monday, November 7, 2022

Movie #698: The Silence of the Lambs

The Silence of the Lambs is a psychological horror film directed by Jonathan Demme and starring Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, Ted Levine, Scott Glenn, Brooke Smith, and Anthony Heald. It's one of only three movies to win the "Big Five" Oscars (Picture, Actor, Actress, Screenplay, Director), which considering the subject matter is interesting. 

Clarice Starling (Foster) is an FBI-agent in training who gets recruited by her mentor Jack Crawford (Glenn) to interview a serial killer in custody, one Hannibal Lecter (Hopkins). Lecter, in addition to being a serial killer, is a cannibal and a renowned psychiatrist (and a gourmet chef, although that doesn't come into the movie as much as in the book). Starling doesn't get very far initially, but Lecter takes an interest and gives her little breadcrumbs leading to information about the Bureau's current white whale, a serial killer nicknamed "Buffalo Bill" (Levine). In the course of the investigation and the cat-and-mouse with Lecter, Lecter manages to manipulate the situation to allow him to escape, and Starling tracks down Bill and winds up shooting him.

I've loved this move since it came out (I was a senior in high school when it won all of the Oscars, or as my dad said at the time "Lecter said 'pick me or you're a pot roast'"), and watching it with my oldest was interesting. The really affecting scenes - Lecter's escape, Buffalo Bill's (Smith) victim screaming in a pit, Clarice stumbling around in the dark as Bill decides where to shoot her, and of course the final scene where Lecter follows Dr. Chilton (Heald) at a leisurely, relaxed pace - have not lost a bit of impact. The score by Howard Shore remains my hands-down favorite movie score of all time; I've used it as game soundtrack many times, and it's my go-to background music when I'm writing a Chill case. Every bit of the cast is pitch-perfect. Foster's Clarice is driven and smart, but not preternaturally so in that kind of pandering way. Scott Glenn is understated and smart but fallible as Jack Crawford (based on John Douglas, whose books I've read, and although behavioral profiling is basically as accurate as cold reading, they're still good reads). Ted Levine really should have had a Supporting Actor nod as Jame Gumb ("Buffalo Bill"), as he tries to be disaffected and feminine but then breaks and yells. And then of course there's Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter, cementing that character in the cultural consciousness.

There's some criticism of the movie, of course; I had a prof in college who took exception with Clarice only beating Gumb through sheer luck (hearing the hammer on his gun click back), but said prof was also very invested in everything being sexist and I don't buy that argument. There was also some flap about the movie being transphobic, which only works if you completely ignore that a major plot point is that Gumb is not trans (they say "transsexual" in the movie, but y'know, 1991). I try to be cognizant of criticism like that because I think it's important to look at older films in a current lens, for the exploration of the evolution of the form if nothing else. In this case, though, I think the truth is just that the movie is about some truly disturbing shit and it's really well done, and that gets under people's skin. So to speak.

My Grade: A
Rewatch Value: Weirdly high

Next up: Silver Bullet

No comments:

Post a Comment