Sunday, October 18, 2020

Movie #593: The Replacements

The Replacements is a sports comedy starring Keanu Reeves, Gene Hackman, Brooke Langton, Rhys Ifans, Jon Favreau, Orlando Jones, Ace Yonamine, Brett Cullen, David Denham, Faizon Love, and Michael Taliferro. 

The NFL players go on strike, demanding more money, and different teams react in different ways. The Washington DC Sentinels respond by hiring scabs to finish the season, and the team's owner (Jack Warden in his final film role) hires Jimmy McGinty (Hackman) to coach this team of "replacements." 

Said replacements include Murphy (Denham), a skilled player who was born deaf and as such can't catch a break; a Welsh soccer player with a gambling problem (Ifans); a pair of brothers working as bodyguards (Love and Taliferro); a Sumo wrestler (Yonamine); and a riot cop action junkie and violent nutcase (Favreau). As their quarterback, he finds Shane Falco (Reeves), a once-promising player who blew his shot when he lost an important game. 

From there, it's a sports movie about a team of misfits, and that's a genre almost as formulaic as a slasher movie or a rom-com. The team takes a while to gel, the Jackson brothers nearly come to blows with Fumiko, and no one really respects Falco because he has a habit of choking when shit gets intense. And then the evil union quarterback Martel (Cullen) picks a fight with the team in a bar, and they all get arrested, and bond when the youngest and greenest of them, Franklin (Jones) leads them in "I Will Survive." 

In the midst of all of this, Falco woos the head cheerleader Annabelle (Langton), and the players deal with their own plotlines (some of which have arcs, some of which just have lines). In the end, they take the team to the playoffs, but then disappear into obscurity, which is about the only way the movie breaks from the formula. 

So, this is a pretty harmless movie. There are a number of fun moments, and the cast in general seems like they're having fun (Hackman in particular, who can often come off as kind of prickly). I think there are two things about it that keep me from liking it more than I do.

First, I know nothing about American football. The tense moments in the movie don't affect me because I have no idea what's happening on the field or why it's significant. I don't know what a "down" is or any of the other terminology. In movies like Major League, I can get at least a little more invested because I know the rules of the game (or at least, I know the grade school version). 

Second, I find it a little hard to root against a union strike, being a public employee myself. The movie addresses this; the NFL players all come off like clueless, spoiled millionaires, refusing to play because they want more millions, but knowing what I do about how the NFL has ignored CTE over the years, it's still a little hard to get behind the central premise. With that said, the cast does a great job of making the characters likeable (even Favreau, whose character is a cop who just loves beating people, which, erm, yeah, that's impressive, Jon), the jokes land, so it's a fun movie.

My Grade: B+
Rewatch Value: Medium-high

Next up: Repo! The Genetic Opera

No comments:

Post a Comment