Tuesday, September 22, 2026

Movie #975: Observe & Report

Observe & Report is a dark comedy starring Seth Rogen, Anna Faris, Ray Liotta, Michael Peña, Collette Wolfe, Jesse Plemmons, Aziz Ansari, Celia Weston, John Yuan, and Matthew Yuan. It's...not great.

Ronnie Barnhardt (Rogen) is the head of mall security at...a mall (I'm sure the name is mentioned but it's not important). He takes himself very seriously. It would be easy to say he takes his job seriously, but that's not remotely accurately - his job is just a way for him to live out his delusions of being a protector and a warrior. And then one day, a flasher (Randy Gambill) shows up and starts...flashing, and shows his junk to Brandi (Faris), a shallow, vapid, cosmetics salesperson who Ronnie happens to fixate on. 

The actual police, in the personage of Detective Harrison (Liotta) show up and try to do actual police work, and Ronnie fucks with the investigation every step of the way. And then the next night, someone vandalizes and burgles the mall, meaning Harrison has to come back again, and Ronnie fucks it all up again. Someone in here gives Ronnie the idea that he should be a cop so he applies, but fails the psych eval (because he has bipolar disorder and has gone off his meds because everything's going so great), we get our Abyss moment, he gets fired, he comes back to the mall, chases down the flasher, and fucking shoots him (nonfatally). 

There's a lot more I'm leaving out - he goes on a date with Brandi, there's a mall employee named Nell (Wolfe) that he flirts and talks with, and of course his right hand man Dennis (Peña, speaking with a strong lisp for some reason) turns out to be the thief. The movie does not work, and I've been trying to think about why. 

I think part of it is that Ronnie is a truly despicable person. Yes, some of that is mental illness (and also his dad left when he was very small, his mom (Weston) is an alcoholic who used to fuck his friends when he was in high school). But Ronnie is a ticking time bomb - he's a gun enthusiast, he's quite capably violent (in a plot decision I don't fully understand, he's shown to be very able to handle multiple opponents in a fight), and he's a misogynst, homophobic, racist, bigot. He sexually assaults Brandi more than once, and then assumes they're dating after their one pretty awful date (which he blackmailed her into). 

But also, the people around Ronnie don't...seem to mind? Like, a lot of people hate him, but his boss (Dan Bakkedahl) puts up with his bullshit for reasons I cannot fathom. Other folks just kind of soak up his abuse, and I have to assume some of it is because they're afraid of him (and rightly so, because he 100% reads as someone who's going to go on a shooting spree at some point), but even people who have the authority to call him out don't. 

Part of the issue is that there are no good or likeable characters in the movie. Like, exactly none. Jesse Plemmons' Charles gets close; he's a mall employee moving up to security guard and serves as a very quiet voice of reason, but then jumps in a fight against a horde of cops to help Ronnie. Nell is pathetic, but other than the fact that she's got a foot cast and can't walk and that she's a "born-again virgin," we never learn anything about her. Even Harrison, who is initially positioned as a cop just trying to do his job, snaps at Ronnie (which is reasonable) but then heaps slurs on him.

So if this is a "watch this character unravel" a la Taxi Driver (which the directed cited as an inspiration), OK, but why make it a comedy? Why try to position Ronnie as this loveable goof (which is what the trailers did)? Ronnie is not lovable, he's scary, and the fact that it's the Ronnie Barnhardts of the world who are now members of ICE just kind of puts a sobering spin on all this.

Dark comedy is tricky at the best of times, and this had some potential, but it did not stick the landing. The only things I can say in its defense is a) the needle drops are good (there's a cover of "Where Is My Mind?" that I quite enjoyed) and b) the awkward moments don't linger too long, which is often a problem in Rogen movies.

My Grade: D-
Rewatch Value: IISNIAIFWT

Next up: The Omega Man

No comments:

Post a Comment