Showing posts with label dream city knights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dream city knights. Show all posts

Sunday, November 22, 2026

Character Creation: Dream City Knights

We are such games as dreams are knighted in, and our little lives around rounded like a peep. 

The Game: Dream City Knights
The Publisher: Edge of Mythos
Degree of Familiarity: None
Books Required: Just the one


Dream City Knights is a cute idea. You're playing teenagers who lucid dream, specifically of the titular Dream City, and fight against the nightmares therein that can bleed into the Waking. It's nothing we haven't seen before - see also Changeling: The Dreaming, Lucid: Sea of Dreams, Dreampunk, and Shattered Dreams. The comparison to Changeling: The Dreaming also works because in this game, you can only dream-walk until you turn 18, and then you can't remember the Dream City anymore and your childlike wonder is snuffed forever. 

I'm of two minds, here. I love the notion that children have a power born of their ability to dream unfettered, but as I've gotten older I've gotten really bored of the idea that adults are incapable of creativity or play or dreams. I mean, lord knows I've met any number of adults who have lost that capacity, or at least they don't have much of it, but tying it to your 18th birthday just seems...I dunno, kinda reductive? 

Anyway, like I said, the game is cute. I've got two major problems with the implementation. One is that it was clearly written by people whose first language wasn't English, and while the translation is clear, the language feels weirdly stilted, especially in the interstitial fiction. The other is that the system is this weird PbtA/FitD hybrid, using clocks and moves and all, but there are so damn many moves that I wonder why they bothered.

Like, not to rant, but the whole reason moves work (when they do) is because you're capturing the kinds of actions that you should be "playing to find out." In Monsterhearts, it's an interesting part of the fiction to discover what happens when you (for example) lash out physically. In Masks, unleashing your powers is part and parcel to the fiction in question and so that's what you should be randomizing. But here, there are (hang on) 20 basic moves, and at that point, why not just take a more FitD approach and have you roll on actions or something? This reminds me more of (ugh) Dead Scare, though at least here the moves have triggers and I can see when you'd roll them.

(And the PDF isn't bookmarked. You know, Chill isn't very well bookmarked - the only bookmarks are for the beginnings of chapters - but at least it's got that. If I had it to do over again, that'd be one of the many things I'd do differently.)

Moving on, let's make a dreamy knight or whatever.


Right, so first we set our Focuses. Oh, right, this is kind of like the sliding traits in Must be Tuesday, and I can choose how "dreaming" vs. "waking" I am. I think I need a theme song, hang on.


That's "Elephant" by Tame Impala. It's a song about someone convinced of their own importance, and like, if I'm a 16-year-old dude, that's...not hard to see. Let's name him Mel Crane. If he's 16 and feels that he is "the elephant in the room," I imagine that Dreaming is going to be a bigger deal to him than the Waking. So how does this work?

OK, I have three Stats, Anima, Ego, and Heart. If I were rolling for a move, I'd roll a d8 and add or subtract a Difficulty and try to get over or under my stat, depending on whether I'm in the Dreaming. So f'rex, if Mel was trying to be the center of attention in the Dreaming, I'd roll a d8, add the Difficulty, and try to get equal to or higher than my Ego. If I were doing it in the Waking, I'd subtract the Difficulty and then try to roll lower. 

(I get it, but pitching this to my gamers would be such a fuckin' headache.)

Anyway, I think I was right, Mel's generally more effective in the Dreaming. So that means I want the numbers to be low. So let's set Anima at 3, Ego at 5, and Heart at 6 (courage and determination but also love for his friends; I think Mel is aware that the Waking world is more "real", maybe). 

Big Dream: This is, in very general terms, what is most important to Mel. That's easy, "I want to be the one that everyone talks about."

Why I'm Cool: This is basically anything that's a positive characteristic. (Though I suspect if you asked Mel why he's cool, he might give Lord Flashheart's answer: "Because I'm me.") In Mel's case, let's say it's "I'm not afraid of anyone."

Personal Nightmare: Again, this one's easy: Mel's afraid of everyone not hating him, but forgetting him or just not thinking about him.

Starting Hobbies: I get to pick 9 points worth of Hobbies, but the max rating for one is 3, so I have to pick at least 3. There's a list, fortunately. I'm gonna pick Youth Scout 3 (Mel is or was an Eagle Scout), Puzzle-Solving 2, Pop Culture 2, and Paintball 2. 

Obsession: Such a great movie. Anyway, this is a specialization of a Hobby that I'm really fixated on. Hmm. I'd love to do one for Paintball, I'm just having trouble figuring one out. Let's say "Battle Plans," how about.

Iconic Item: This is something important to Mel that might manifest different in the Dreaming. I think Mel carries a Swiss Army knife that becomes a gleaming sword in the Dreaming.

Favorite Spot: Paintball course, obviously.

Age: 16, covered that. I've only got 2 more years of magic! But there's no spot for age on the character sheet, so it can't be that important. Oh, wait! It is important, because for every year over 13, I get to either improve a Hobby by 2, 2 Hobbies by 1, or pick a Talent! 

Well, shit. I'll bump Paintball and Pop Culture to 3. And then I'll two Talents, I'll take Daredevil and Rumor Miller.

Cool name: Did that already.

Mel is 16, black hair, blue eyes, and he's got such a baby face. He tries to stay tan and in shape so he reads more like his age and less like he's 12, and sometimes it works. He'd love to grow facial hair but every time he tries he looks like a hobo (his mom's words) so he always shaves it. He's gotten in trouble for carrying his knife at school so he usually leaves it in his jacket or his locker, but he always has it nearby. 

That'll do it!