Aah! Squids!
The Game: Cthulhu Hack 2nd Ed
The Publisher: Just Crunch? Published by All Rolled Up? Who can say?
Degree of Familiarity: Some with Lovecraft's work, never played this game
Books Required: Just the one
The Cthulhu Hack is one of the many RPGs based on Lovecraft's work, and apparently derivative of the "Black Hack", one of the many revisions of 1st Ed D&D for the "OSR" crowd. I don't have any particular love for OSR as a design philosophy, largely because I think making D&D 1st Ed clones is a lot like making silent movies - sure, you can, and you can even do it well, but like...why?
Anyway, Cthulhu Hack looks like a perfectly solid way to play Mythos/cosmic/investigative horror, but I run up against the same problem I always do when I read games like this: Is it better for investigative horror than Chill 3rd Ed? Is it better at Mythos horror than Trail of Cthulhu? Does it do something unique and interesting with that kind of play experience, like tremulus? Those are kinda my go-to games for this kind of thing, and while I appreciate how cleanly laid out and well-written Hack is, the inclusion of the six D&D stats for Saves just kinda makes me go "ugh."
All of this to say: It looks perfectly playable and the production design is great, I just think I have games I like better for this. But let's make an investigator!
So, I can do this one of two ways. I can pick an Archetype and do a little tweaking (but most of the work is already done), or I can make a character from scratch, which isn't that much more work. Since I'm working from home today and I don't actually have much to do, let's do the slightly longer version.
So, first thing we do is roll saves, which means we roll 2d6+6 six times and assign them in whatever order we like. Hrm, guess I need a concept. Hang on, let's pick a song.
"Fly on the Windscreen," by Depeche Mode. Last theme song I picked randomly was also Depeche Mode, but this is pretty appropriate for this game so I'm gonna keep it. This suggests a certain kind of nihilism, but why is such a character delving into forbidden knowledge? The song is really about love (or lust) in the face of destruction and death, so I can see this character being a kind of Cassandra, with a perhaps greater-than-average understanding of the cosmic shit that the world is in, but no way to express it. If we're in the usual setting for Mythos games (that 20s or 30s), that might make him part of the counterculture.
That's a good enough start that I can roll some dice. Rolling 2d6+6 six times, I get: 15, 8 (ugh), 11, 16, 11, 9. Geez, I'm gonna die quick (which is fine). Well, in line with that, I'll put my low Saves in Constitution and Strength. I'll put my 11s in Dexterity and Intelligence, the 15 in Wisdom, and the 16 in Charisma.
Next we do Resource dice. These start at 1d4 (or 1, in the case of Armed and Unarmed) and increased by dice steps from there. I get 10 "steps" to throw around, and I have six to worry about.
Well, Hit Dice seems like it should get some love, so I'll put a dice there, putting it up to 1d6. Flashlights and Smokes are investigative resources devoted to get clues by either looking for them or dealing with people (respectively), and both of those seem like something my guy should be decent at, though maybe better at Smokes? So let's put two dice into Flashlights and three into Smokes, making those stats 1d8 and 1d10, respectively.
That leaves Sanity and the two damage stats, and four steps left. You know what, let's just dump all four into Sanity, putting it up to d12. I like the idea that he's going into this clear-eyed.
Hit points is weird; I roll all of the dice he has for Hit Dice, which is 1d4+1d6, which is (roll) 5. Yep, gonna die.
And now I get three Special Abilities and one Skill. Let's check it out!
Well, I want Deduction (once per game I can require the GM to give me a hint). Oh, I love If You Hum It; I can roll a Save on someone else's value, but failure affects us both. And finally, let's take ...Is My Middle Name; once per game I can declare Advantage as if my Occupation were something other than what it is.
Skill, then. I guess I should develop this guy a little more. His name is Cassler Hammond. Cassler (it's a family name) comes from money, but he's gambled away most of what he was given. He borrows money as he can and rarely pays it back, because man, we're all going to burn anyway. I'll take Gambling as his Skill, then? Actually, no, I'll say his Occupation is Gambler, but I want his skill to be a kind of "get everyone to nod along" kind of thing, so let's call that Oration.
And that's basically it! I see Cassler as being skinny and wasted; he's spent a lot of time high and he's the type to forego dinner to keep playing baccarat or whatever. He's balding and some of his back teeth are starting to get bad, but he keeps smiling (and drinking), because really, what's the alternative? Weep as the world end? Never.


