Tuesday, September 20, 2022

Movie #694: Shutter Island

Shutter Island is a psychological-horror sort of thing directed by Martin Scorsese and starring Leonardo DiCaprio, Mark Ruffalo, Ben Kingsley, Emily Mortimer, Michelle Williams, Jackie Earle Haley, Max von Sydow, Patrica Clarkson, Ted Levine, holy shit, the list just goes on.

Teddy Daniels (DiCaprio) is a US Marshall who arrives on Shutter Island, a mental institution/prison, with his partner Chuck (Ruffalo) to search for a missing patient, a woman named Rachel Solando (Mortimer). Rachel apparently just up and vanished from her room, but like, it's an island, how far could she get? But there's a hurricane coming...and who's this weird German scientist named Naehring (von Sydow)? Why does this give Teddy, a WWII vet, such big Nazi death-camp vibes?

Teddy goes to work peeling back the layers of this onion, learning and revealing more about the island, its history, the doctor in charge (Kingsley), his own partner, and the nightmares he keeps having of his dead wife (Williams), until it all comes to a head in a lighthouse where Teddy learns the truth. He's here because he killed his wife, because she killed their children, and his mind snapped and created this fantasy rather than deal with it all. (Spoilers for a 12-year-old movie, I guess.)

Shutter Island is nicely gothic in its sensibilities, and we get a good feel for the island and its topography as the movie goes along. It also does a nice job of ratcheting up the paranoia as Teddy gets closer to the truth, and therefore his mind pushes him further into delusion. 

With that said, as with a lot of Scorsese movies, I feel like there are some bits that could have been tightened up a little. Ted Levine's character doesn't seem to add much to the proceedings, and he's just one more weirdo getting lost in the shuffle by the time he shows up. Characters tend to pop in, have one pivotal scene, and then pop out again, and that's not bad, I guess, but it does make a lot of the characters feel kind of one-note. The nightmares of Michelle Williams and the Dachau concentration camp blend reality and delusion, but I do wonder if the movie plays fair by the audience - watching it this time and knowing the truth, I didn't see a lot of clues that hinted as to the reality of the situation. 

But, with that said, DiCaprio turns in a good performance; this was kind of a warm-up for Inception, in some ways. Mark Ruffalo has a real knack for being worried and understated, and of course Ben Kingsley is perfect as usual. Michelle Williams has a real standout scene in her final scene with DiCaprio, too.

My Grade: B+
Rewatch Value: Medium

Next up: Sicko

No comments:

Post a Comment