Tuesday, April 28, 2020

Character Creation: Shadows of Esteren

You know, I really wanted to like this game. Ah, well.

The Game: Shadows of Esteren
The Publisher: Studio Agate 
Degree of Familiarity: None, and the book didn't hook me
Books Required: Just the one

Shadows of Esteren is described on their website as a crossmedia project. It's an RPG! Music! Board games! It slices and dices!

And that's fine, that's not remotely where I have a problem. My issue is that the first 200 pages of the first core book (which is all you need to play, unless you want the complete setting) is all in-character setting info. And like, over the years I've cooled on that as a means of conveying setting info. Sure, unreliable narrators make for interesting conflicts, and sure, presenting in-character documents are a potentially interesting way of showing history and bias, but that requires them to have a strong hook to bring a reader in, and I didn't find that this book had it.

And admittedly, some of this is my usual bugaboo with fantasy as a genre, but I just found the writing dry. I will say, though, that the artwork and the production design are fabulous, so that's nice.

Anyway, I tried to get through the setting chapters, I really did, but my eyes kept glazing over and so I'm gonna jump right to the character creation section and hope that contextualizes enough that I can use it.

Step One is to choose an ethnicity. None of them really pass the Chupp test, so I'm just gonna be basic and say my character is Tri-Kazelian.

Step Two: Profession, Birthplace, and Social Class. Why are these all wrapped up in one step, but Ethnicity is its own? Weird.

Well, let's start with Profession, since that's next in the book.

Hmm. There's vaguely magicky things available; you can be a "magientist" or a druid-like thing, but the magic in this game is supposedly very subtle. The last couple fantasy characters I've made have been pretty rugged, so I think I'll go a little more cosmopolitan and make a Merchant. That makes my primary domain Relation, and I can choose Erudition or Craft as my secondary. I'll go with Craft, I think.

I get two more Domains at 2, and two at 1. I want to take Erudition at 2, so I'm not illiterate. Think I'll take Feats at 1 (that's like athletics). Also Perception at 1. For my other 2...hmm. Let's say Science.

Birthplace! I don't actually have to name it, I just need to decide if I grew up in a city and was therefore conscripted for a year, or not. I'm gonna say I was, so I get a point in Close Combat and another point in Relation, which puts me over 5, so then what happens? I get a point in a Discipline. What's that? Ah, OK. Once you get over 5 in a domain, you have to specialize, so a Discipline is a refinement of a domain but it's rated 6 to 15. So I'll take Persuasion as my Discipline.

Social class! Commoner, obviously, but more middle class, so I get to choose two of Craft, Erudition, Performance, and Relation to raise. I'll do Craft and Relation again, so I can put Diplomacy as a Discipline.

Step Three: The Ways. I thought at first that these were the basic attribute like things, but upon further reading they're a little more complicated. Ways are mental characteristics and they seem to have more to do with how a character approaches things. I get ratings of 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 (that's the kind of combination an idiot would have on his luggage!) in my Ways. Having a high rating gives me bonuses to certain Domains, but it also apparently makes me prone to Faults.

Anyway, I'll put my 1 in Conviction (it's not that my guy doesn't understand living for a cause, it just doesn't suit him). I'll put 2 into Combativeness, 3 into Reason, 4 into Empathy, and 5 into Creativity.

Step Four: Age, Setbacks, and History. Oh, now, this is cool. I can choose to be older (though no older than 35), and if I am I get more skill points, but I also have Setbacks. Well, I want at least some life experience, so I'll say my character is 28, so I get two more Domain points but also two Setbacks. I'll put one point into Craft and one into Travel, and then I have to roll for Setbacks, which is only fitting.

First off, I get a Wound, resulting in a one-point penalty to Stamina. I'll say that my character was moving a bunch of goods from a wagon and something spooked the horse. It pitched forward and my character fell under the wagon wheel, breaking his leg.

Next, I get an Adversary. I'll say that the lord of a nearby province bought some good from me, but when he got them, they were ruined (broken, rotten, I'll figure that out later). My character to this day swears it wasn't his fault, but the lord blames me and he's not the most stable of people.

And now I do history, which is basically just that. My character's name is Oarel. He was raised in Baldh-Ruoch; his family were crafters and carpenters. Oarel, however, demonstrated a knack of money, for buying and selling, and sometimes just trading (after all, as Oarel's uncle was fond of saying, money is just a symbol, so it's better to get goods and services than coin). Over the years he's made and broken many different deals, and he's got his fair share of loyal partners and customers as well as people who swear they wouldn't cross the street to spit in his eye. It isn't that he's immoral or even amoral, it's just that sometimes deals fall through, and can he be blamed for that?

Step Five: Traits, Sanity, and Personality. First off I get two traits, based on my Ways. One's a quality and one's a flaw. Hmm. Well, I think I'll take the flaw in Conviction and say that Oarel is inconstant. I'll take the quality in creativity and say he's inventive.

Consciousness is Reason + Conviction, which is 4. Instinct is Combativeness + Creativity (7). Trauma starts at 0. That means my orientation is instinctive...oh, but wait, I get Trauma equal to the difference, so 3.

Mental Resistance is Conviction + 5, so 6. Except it can be changed by Advantages and Disadvantages. Is there some virus that makes game designers put derived traits before things that can change them in the process?

Anyway, Sanity. I start off in the Balance section, but the book also says that to use these rules, we have to read the Sanity chapter (!). Think I'll skip it.

Step Six: Experience Points, Advantages, Disadvantages. And now I get 100 XP to spend, and I can get more by taking Disadvantages, but I don't like any of them so I shan't. I will, however, say that I have some money set aside, so I'll spent 10 points on Financial Ease. I have 90 left, and none of the other Advantages sing to me, so I'll dump them into Domains (for 9 points). I'll take points in Erudition, two in Perception, one in Performance, one in Science, one in Shooting/Throwing, two in Stealth, and one more in Travel.

Step Seven: Potential, Defense, Speed, and Stamina. God, these divisions of steps are so damn arbitrary. I have 3 Fighting Potential, 12 Defense, 6 Speed, 9 Stamina (should be 10, but that wound).

Step Eight: Fighting Attitudes and Attack Rating. These are just how combat numbers shift depending on how you fight. Looks like a cool system, but it's not something I feel like puzzling through.

Step Nine: Survival Points, Rindath, Exaltation. Now we're just making up words. Survival Points is 3 for a starting character. Rindath is 11, but it doesn't matter because I don't do magic. Exaltation, likewise, isn't important for me because I'm not a priest, but it's 3 if anyone asks.

Step Ten: Description and Equipment. Holy shit. OK, so Oarel is a sturdy-looking man in his late 20s. He's got sandy brown hair and a well-kept beard, and he walks with the aid of a walking stick (more when it gets cold). He wears clothes that are maybe a little too nice for him, but he's a little vain. He eschews weapons; he doesn't ever want to send the message that things could devolve into violence because if that happens, ain't nobody getting paid.

I think it'd be interesting to play Oarel as the PC who's paying everyone else, at least at first. Not sure I've ever been in that kind of game, where one player-controlled character hired the others. I mean, stuff like Leverage where it's assumed, but nothing where there's actually a money system.

Speaking of which, I ain't shopping. That's me done.

No comments:

Post a Comment