Showing posts with label adventures in the east mark. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adventures in the east mark. Show all posts

Sunday, November 6, 2022

Character Creation: Adventures in the East Mark

Happy "extra hour of sleep but it gets dark at 4PM and my brain thinks that's just great because my brain wants me dead" day to all who celebrate.

The Game: Adventures in the East Mark
The Publisher: Gallant Knight Games
Degree of Familiarity: I mean, I think I played red box D&D back in the day once or twice
Books Required: Just the one

This is another D&D clone, and more specifically it's an English translation of a Spanish retro-clone of Classic Dungeons & Dragons. I'm not as well-versed in the history of the various editions and revisions of D&D as I am in, say, the revisions and evolution of WoD games, so I can't speak with any authority about when this version was big or on this particular game (some more context here, though). All I can say is that I do not understand why a retro-clone of basic D&D is...necessary?

Like, I don't mean to shit on D&D here, it just feels like making a clone of Monopoly. There's nostalgia value, sure, and a lot of people know about it, but it's just so basic. Surely there's a way to achieve what you love about the thing you're cloning without cloning its warts and funny smell, too? But since I don't really understand what's so great about early-edition D&D and its ilk, I suspect I am not the target audience here.

Or, put another way, Adventures in the East Mark looks perfectly playable and it's got good production values, but I cannot imagine pitching it to any of my groups. Want to play a high-lethality fantasy game? Sure, we could play this one and make up the setting as we go or...we could play Shadow of the Demon Lord or Xas Irralka. Want to play a setting-agnostic game and make up the setting as we go? Sure, we could play this, or we could play any number of games that do exactly that and pay some attention to narrative currency as well as combat systems. Want to play D&D? Sure, we could play this, or we could play 5e, which acknowledges (at least to a point) how game design has evolved in the last 40 years.

Anyway, I've had this game on my list for a long time and every time I opened it I do the Patton Oswalt "nnooOOOOOOooooo" thing, so let's do it and then put it away. 

OK, characteristics first, the standard D&D spread. We're meant to roll 3d6 for each, in order, though the book notes that a particularly magnanimous GM could allow us to roll 4d6 and drop the lowest. I'll just go old-school, I think. This gives me:

Strength 10
Dexterity 13
Constitution 11
Intelligence 12
Wisdom 11
Charisma 15

That's actually not bad. Nothing hugely amazing, but nothing in the basement, either. 

Now we fill in some derived traits...most of them are 0 because most of my stats are in that 9-12 range, but I'll do OK with NPC reactions. Maybe I'll make a bard if that's a thing.

Speaking of which, time to pick a class! This being a 1st ed clone, Elf and Dwarf and Halfling are classes rather than races. I need to meet certain prerequisites for some of the classes, and my middling-ass stats might hurt me there, but let's see what's on the table. 

Actually, the requirements are pretty low, generally. I can't be an explorer or a paladin because my STR is too low, but everything else is available. Hmm. What have I not done in fantasy games? I actually don't know, I know I've made a cleric and I know I've done magic-users. It runs in my head I did a thief or rogue or something at one point, but buggered if I can remember where.

Well, let's do this. My highest stats are Dex and Cha. Let's find a class that plays to those. Elf, sounds good. I've made elf characters in other fantasy games, but I like archers and precision-fighters, and a little mating magic wouldn't hurt.

Ahem. AC is [whatever the armor gives me] -1 for my Dex mod, so that'll wait for now. Hit points...my hit dice is 1d6, I roll that (3), I don't have a Con modifier, so that's 3 HP for me. Saving throws are fixed values, and they kinda suck (now, see, the flavor text for elves indicates that we're "tough as oaks," but then my fucking save vs. spell and magic weapons is 15, so which is it?). 

Alignment is lawful, neutral, or chaotic. Chaotic is described as "evil" and "selfish", which isn't really what "chaotic" means, but whatever. I'll say my guy is lawful. He can be an uptight and conservative sort of elf, the kind of guy that wouldn't want his daughter marrying a human. Worked for Elrond.

And...what else? I feel like I get a spell or something. Also there are supposedly skills...this chargen is really badly laid out, now that I'm digging into it. The info is never all summarized in one place. Oh, wait, I guess I get to detect hidden doors on a 1-2 on a 1d6 (fuck me, pick a system and stay with it). 

Spells? The level chart just says 1 level 1 spell at level 1 (arglebarlge), but the magic chapter:

Have I mentioned how much I hate memorization-based magic systems? 'Cause it's a lot. Anyway, this looks like I get 3 level 1 spells (since I get 1, and then two "additional" ones) and one level 2, but I can only use one of the level 1 spells. Yay, I can write them on my sheet and dream. 

Well, given that my elf is a forthright champion for the light, Protection Against Evil makes sense. And then for my two that I know but can't use, I'll take Magic Missile and Read Magic. For my useless level 2, I'll take Detect Evil. 

Equipment! I get 3d8 x 10 gold, so hang on...60. Ugh. I'm a poor elf. Well, a short bow is 16, 10 arrows is 3, leather armor is 20 (and sets my AC at 6, including my Dex modifier). 21 gold left. A long sword and a dagger, sure, that's 13 total, meaning I have 8 left.

That's basically all; I could start buying bedrolls and feathers and shit, but I ain't gonna. Let's just wrap this elf up.

Ylyndar Zalarus is a high elf, tall and willowy, with hair the color of cornsilk and pale blue eyes. He's young as elves go, and is pretty convinced of his people's superiority - not in a "we should kill you all, inferior pigs" kind of way, but more of a "tsk, tsk, those poor humans/dwarves/whatever" way. Ylyndar's motivation for adventuring is one part seeking glory to four parts extolling the majesty of elf culture. I'd say that's going to get him in trouble, but the truth of the matter is that a gibbon with a toothpick could probably manage to do 3 damage to him. 

That'll do it!